Editor-in-chief
Currently, the healthcare system is faced with the task to implement clinical guidelines into clinical practice, which requires an assessment of needs for resource support for the provision of medical care. Starting from 2019, standards of medical care are being developed based on clinical guidelines. The study assessed the possibility of planning the resource support for the provision of medical care for cancer diseases according to the standards of medical care developed on the basis of clinical guidelines. As a result, it was shown that the standards of medical care approved by the order of the Ministry of Health of Russia make it possible to assess the need for medicines and the number of cots. Wherein the digital prototype of medical care standards allows for a more detailed assessment and in terms of the conditions for providing medical care, types and methods of antitumor treatment, as well as additionally assessing the need for medical care and medical personnel. So currently the standards of medical care developed on the basis of the clinical guidelines can be considered as a tool for managing the organization of cancer care.
This paper analyzes and presents the results of a study of objective and subjective reasons for leaving the place of permanent residence to another region of your country or a foreign country in order to receive medical care there, depending on the degree of influence of such reasons on the final decision. For this purpose, a survey of German-speaking, English-speaking and Russian-speaking respondents was conducted using the questionnaire method. The total number of respondents from different countries was more than 150 people.
During pregnancy, a woman's health undergoes major physical and psychological changes. Even in uncomplicated pregnancies, these changes can affect the physical component of the pregnant woman's quality of life, as well as the health of the mother and fetus. Earlier attempts have been made to study the quality of life c physiologic pregnancy and assessed the associated socio-demographic, physical and psychological factors in developed countries, in addition, a systematic review was published in 2018. The diagnosis of gestational diabetes mellitus is associated with the risk of adverse pregnancy outcomes for both mother and fetus, which may negatively affect quality of life. The objectives of the present study were to investigate the characteristics of quality of life in pregnant women with of gestational diabetes mellitus in comparison with women with physiologically normal pregnancy. This work is part of further planned research to analyze the risks of reduced public health quality in the management of pregnant women with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Materials and Methods. From Maya 2023 to January 2024, a sociological survey of 553 pregnant women referred for consultation with an endocrinologist at the consultative and diagnostic department of the perinatal center of the S.S.Yudin State Clinical Hospital in Moscow was conducted using online questionnaires. The SF-36 questionnaire (The Short Form-36) is an international questionnaire used to study the quality of life, validated in Russia. The socio-demographic characteristics block of the questionnaire was adapted by the authors of the study to interview pregnant women. The aim of the present study was to further contribute to the knowledge of the clinical relationship between of gestational diabetes mellitus and physical and psychological components of the quality of life of pregnant women.
Compliance with ethical standards: the study was approved by the Interuniversity Ethics Committee, Protocol No. 4 of 13.04.2023. Respondents signed informed consent to participate in the study, and gave consent to publish the results of sociological surveys.
Results. The study revealed that the physical component of quality of life was statistically significantly reduced in pregnant women with of gestational diabetes mellitus. The leading factors determining the physical functioning of the mother are pregnancy term and age. The decrease of the physical component of pregnant women with of gestational diabetes mellitus quality of life deserves serious attention for the development of unified programs for pregnant women with of gestational diabetes mellitus as part of a strategy to counter the risks of deterioration in the quality of public health of pregnant women associated with medical and social determinants of public health. Such unified programs for pregnant women with of gestational diabetes mellitus must include dosed physical activity, training in the principles of diet therapy and psychological self-regulation to form pregnant women’s with of gestational diabetes mellitus commitment to a healthy lifestyle. In the development and implementation of such programs for pregnant women with of gestational diabetes mellitus, endocrinologists, medical psychologists, and exercise therapy doctors should take an active part, along with obstetricians and gynecologists.
The decrease in the physical component of quality of life in pregnant women with GDM certainly deserves attention for the development of individual/universal programs of dosed physical activity, teaching the principles of nutritional therapy in the direction of the formation of commitment to a healthy lifestyle in pregnant women. Detection of a pathological condition in a future mother is always a stressful factor, in this regard, psychological counseling/work with a psychologist seems reasonable to improve the care and quality of life of pregnant women with of gestational diabetes mellitus.
The article identifies the key tasks of national healthcare at the present stage. The exceptional role of primary health care in maintaining the health of the nation has been revealed. The dependence of the guarantee of accessibility of primary health care on the level of provision of primary health care personnel is noted. The problem of shortage of qualified medical workers has been identified,
which results in a decrease in the quality of medical services provided. The study revealed a discrepancy between the labor intensity of medical workers and the amount of monetary remuneration they receive, which has a negative impact on motivation in terms of fulfilling professional duties. A study of the cost structure of primary care workers' working hours has shown that almost 50% of the time is spent filling out documentation, reducing work efficiency, staff interest and engagement. Given the high work intensity, responsibility for decisions made, as well as the different attitudes of employees towards their motivation, the following conclusion is drawn. When forming an incentive system, it is considered necessary to apply an integrated approach that includes both tangible and intangible incentive methods. This will ensure not only the maximum interest of primary care workers, but also increase the prestige of the profession, which, to some extent, will solve the problem of the shortage of qualified personnel.
In article the materials demonstrating to the disordered application in territorial subjects of the Russian Federation of mobile divisions of the medical organizations that demands improvement of legal regulation of their activity are stated analytically. The made analysis confirms also importance of use of the new strategy at the organization of delivery of health care based not only on growth of financing of health care and volumes of medical services, but also on estimates of the achieved results in preservation and improvement of human health at individual, group and (or) population level.
The article deals with the issues of work, staffing, principles of formation, development of the personnel potential of doctors of specialists of individual companies of medical reinforcement during the Great Patriotic War.
The article provides a comparative analysis of international standards for the quality of medical activities in comparison with the criteria for assessing the quality of medical care regulated by Order of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation No. 203n. Similar procedures and discrepancies were identified in the regulations for assessing medical care in outpatient settings from the standpoint of the quality and safety of medical activities. By applying the norms of international standards for the quality of medical activities in the practice of medical organizations in the Russian Federation, it is possible to improve the quality and safety of medical activities.
Multifactorial negative etiology of medical and demographic indicators of the rural population is worse than the urban one.
A new organizational technology “Paramedic Assistant” is proposed in small settlements, tested in the Orenburg region. Positive results
of the project were obtained: visits to people with limited mobility increased by 2.8 times (from 237 people in 2022 to 836 in 2023), and
the number of visits to residents increased by 2 times
Modern challenges for Russian healthcare certainly require a revision of approaches to the provision of medical care, the use of information technology, improving the availability and quality of medical care while reducing the cost of medical services. The development of telemedicine technologies, the legal regulation of which is becoming more and more detailed and specific, contributes to the solution of the tasks set.
The article provides a comparative analysis of regulations governing the provision of paid medical services. It has been established that there is no specification of state guarantees for the provision of free medical care, and in practice, legal mechanisms for distinguishing between free medical care and paid medical services actually do not exist.
Medico-geographical research is an applied field of medical geography aimed at studying and evaluating the spatial spread of diseases and the placement of objects of territorial health systems. As a research method, medical and social mapping makes it possible to assess the spatial accessibility of social infrastructure and reduce social inequality in public access to medical care. In the presented work, a scientific review of works reflecting the problem of inequality and accessibility of medical care in the context of medical and geographical research is carried out. It is concluded that medico-geographical studies, which focus on the spatial placement of medical facilities, make a major contribution to solving the problem of spatial accessibility of medical care and reducing inequality.
The analysis of the results of preventive medical examinations of minors revealed insufficient coverage of children with preventive examinations and negative trends in learner health. To address this issue, a specialist needs to be involved in providing medical care for minors in educational institutions.
The continuing shortage of medical personnel in the country, along with changes in pension legislation, make it very relevant to study the health of doctors and preserve their work activity. This is especially true of doctors of pre-retirement age, the morbidity and mortality among whom is high in the working age.
The purpose of the study is to study the structure, dynamics and mortality rate of doctors of pre-retirement age in the Republic of Tatarstan.
Materials and methods. The study was conducted in the period from 2018 to 2022. The pre-retirement age group corresponded to the age range of 50—59 years for female doctors and 55—64 years for men. The number of doctors of the studied age group was taken from the Federal Register of Medical Workers. The study of the mortality of doctors was carried out by copying the data into a specially designed card from the «Medical death Certificate». 295 cases were analyzed for the period 2018—2022. Statistical analysis was carried out by the Stattech 3.1.0 software package.
Results. Over a 5-year period, the number of doctors in the study group decreased by 1,190 people or by 31.6%. The number of male doctors decreased by 239 people or 21.9%, and female doctors by 951 people or 35.6%. Over the period from 2018 to 2020, the mortality rate among male and female doctors increased sharply against the background of the coronavirus pandemic by 3.8 times. From 2018 to 2022, 295 doctors of pre-retirement age died, which is 7.8% in relation to the entire study group and 24.8% in relation to those who left the register of doctors in 5 years.
Conclusions. The data obtained indicate a two-fold higher mortality rate of doctors of pre-retirement age compared to the population of this age group.
Digitalization extends to all spheres of public life and branches of the functioning of the state, including the healthcare sector, including primary health care. At the same time, the effectiveness of the introduction of innovative technologies directly depends on the level of their use and the general perception of the population. The purpose of this study is to analyze the opinions of patients about the process of digitalization of medical organizations providing primary health care. The materials and methods include the analysis of scientific articles and information from Internet sources relevant to the declared topic, as well as conducting a questionnaire. Data collection was carried out in the period from June to September 2023 and covered 48 subjects of Russia. The survey was conducted using the online service «Yandex.Forms» and included 2437 patients of medical organizations. This article presents an analysis of the results on eight key questions of the questionnaire, which were selected to assess the opinion of patients regarding the process of digitalization of primary health care. As a result of the study, it was revealed that the majority of respondents have a positive attitude to digitalization in medical organizations providing primary health care, but additional improvements are required, such as greater participation of medical personnel and patients in digital technologies, specialized portals, expansion of telemedicine and innovative services.
Telemedicine uses modern communication, electronic and computer technologies to facilitate the remote collection, storage, processing, transmission and query of various health information to expand patient access to health services by overcoming geographical barriers. Many studies have proven that telemedicine can help avoid long-distance patient transport, thereby saving time and costs for patients and improving the quality of care provided to them. To date, some information has accumulated on the possibility of telemedicine to improve the quality of patient care and reduce the rate of hospital readmission. At the same time, there are a number of problems in the telemedicine system.
The purpose of the study: To scientifically substantiate the importance of a responsible attitude to one's own health as a social characteristic of a patient in the formation of his attitude to the organization of medical care provided in outpatient settings. Materials and methods of research. The primary data were obtained by interviewing patients of medical organizations providing medical care on an outpatient basis. A total of 502 questionnaires were distributed, and a response was received from all respondents. The study was conducted in Moscow. The main group consisted of 420 patients who recognized primary responsibility for their health (active behavior model), the control group consisted of 82 patients who assigned primary responsibility for their health to external subjects (passive behavior model). Results. The integral assessment of the activities of medical organizations providing medical care on an outpatient basis does not depend on the fact that the patient recognizes primary responsibility for his health (3.37±0.05 vs. 3.41±0.13 points). Regardless of the fact that the primary responsibility for one's health is recognized, the value of the assessment increases with an increase in the frequency of visits to a medical organization. More strictly, the patients assessed the activities of the city (district) administration on the organization of medical care (3.24±0.06 points in the main group and 3.34±0.14 points in the control group). Patients who take primary responsibility for their health are somewhat more likely to suffer from acute diseases, but less likely to have chronic diseases. The main complaints of patients concerned the organization of work of district doctors and narrow specialists.
This article presents an analysis of the opinion of the population on the participation of a person in the program of preventive examinations and medical examinations and his commitment to the preservation and promotion of health based on a sociological survey of 385 people in the city of Moscow.
The study analyzed the procedures for the provision of medical care (in the profiles of nephrology, audiology, rheumatology
and transfusiology) in order to assess the actual content of mandatory requirements in them, that is, provisions that are unambiguous and imperative, and are subject to subsequent control. It was revealed that such provisions out of the total number are no more than 15%, while the documents do not regulate entire «blocks» of providing medical care, for example, in a day hospital in the profiles of surdology-otolaryngology and rheumatology; for the pediatric population in the profile of nephrology. This situation makes it impossible to conduct mass quality control of medical care, including with the use of information systems. In addition, it has a negative impact on attracting foreign tourists, and also does not allow for optimal planning of resources and costs within public-private partnership projects.
The study evaluates the costs of medical treatment of patients suffering from narcological disorders in a 24-hour hospital with various diagnoses according to ICD — 10. The aim of the study is to assess some characteristics of the costs of the drug treatment used for patients with various drug-related diseases when providing them with medical care in inpatient settings, taking into account the variability of costs, the degree of their compliance with clinical recommendations, and the average cost. Materials and methods. The calculation of the characteristics of drug costs in four groups of patients with the most common diagnoses according to the profile «narcology» was made. 200 medical records of an inpatient patient — case histories (form No. 003/y) of patients who underwent treatment in the hospital of the state budgetary healthcare Institution (GBUZ) «Samara Regional Clinical Narcological Dispensary» in 2022 were analyzed. The cost variation coefficient was calculated, and the average cost values for medicines (in rubles) were compared. It is also determined what proportion of the cost of medicines falls on the drugs recommended by clinical protocols, or groups of drugs. Analytical and statistical research methods were used. Results. The average cost of medical treatment per hospitalization for all diagnoses amounted to 1969.1±157.5 rubles. with the highest costs for the treatment of withdrawal caused by opioid use (2189.7 ± 176.4 rubles) and the lowest costs for the treatment of uncomplicated withdrawal caused by alcohol use (1484.6 ±145.7 rubles). In general, for all groups of patients, the share of costs for the groups of medicines recommended in the clinical recommendations is 58.3%, which is quite low. High values of the coefficient of variation of drug costs in the studied groups were obtained from 33.2% for opioid dependence syndrome to 56.9% in the group of patients with alcohol dependence syndrome undergoing aversive treatment. The cost of medicines for the treatment of patients diagnosed with uncomplicated withdrawal caused by alcohol consumption had a significant difference from the cost of drug treatment of patients of other groups. Conclusion. Despite the high rates of the coefficient of variation of costs and the presence of statistically significant differences in the average cost of inpatient treatment of some groups of patients, it is premature to draw conclusions about the need to increase the number of clinical and statistical groups (CSG) in the profile of «narcology» with budgetary financing of the system, based on the difference in the cost of medicines. It is correct to compare the average cost values in groups with different diagnoses with comparably high levels of spending on medicines included in clinical recommendations.
Currently, information technologies are increasingly used in the provision of medical services. In Russia, the use of telemedicine is already a reality. With the help of remote technologies, assistance was provided during the Pandemic. However, the attitude of society to medical innovations is different. The purpose of the article is to study the attitude / level of trust in the possibilities of using telemedicine technologies in the gender aspect. In the article, the authors set and solve two main tasks in the article: to assess the prevalence of telemedicine technologies in the Russian practice of medical care, as well as to study the attitude and assess the level of confidence in these innovations, taking into account gender differences in the perception of IT in medicine. The article uses the «classic» design of the study in the format of analyzing secondary and obtaining primary data based on the author's sociological survey. The results showed that, in general, men trust telemedicine to a lesser extent than women. However, the older generation of men are not so skeptical than those aged 30 to 49 years. 57% of men agree to get an online appointment with a therapist. There are only a third of them among women, which also confirms the gender difference in the perception of TM. The results obtained have theoretical and practical significance for scientists, researchers and specialists who study the peculiarities of society's attitude to innovations in everyday life, taking into account gender stereotypes, as well as for various government structures, for making balanced and effective decisions in the field of Russian healthcare development.
Medical and demographic analysis of the inter-district nature in certain regions is the basis of the organizational and methodological justification of the clinical and managerial improvement of various health subsystems. Primary medical care of the inter-district level refers to the most important component of maintaining the health of various medical and demographic groups. The research of the dynamics of medical and demographic processes includes the birth rate, incidence, mortality, the ratio of marriages and divorces, the migration of the population, as well as an assessment of the medical function of patients. On these results, it becomes possible to apply models of improving regional healthcare, developing and introducing new, more effective and affordable management technologies. The purpose of this fragment of the study was a regional medical and demographic dynamic analysis at the level of the Udmurt Republic for two decades 2002—2022 with the forecast of trends until 2030. A dynamic analysis of general and primary morbidity, mortality and maternal mortality, the intensity of divorces, marriages and migrations, and the dynamics of the population is assigned to the subject of the research. Based on the results, the development of practical recommendations was made to preserve human capital as socio-economic potential. The data of the Federal State Statistics Service and the Republican Medical Information and Analytical Center of the Ministry of Health of the Udmurt Republic for 2002—2022 were used. The forecast of medical and demographic trends was carried out using the R2 (determination coefficient). Medical and demographic analysis showed that in the region over the past 20 years, the total population, predominant due to urban age at the age of 18—65 years, has been progressively reduced. The main causes of depopulation have a progressive increase in primary and general incidence of adults, maternal incidence and mortality, and a high level of migration of young people under the age of 34 to other regions. In order to solve the problem of increasing the population of the region, based on improving public health, it is planned to introduce the competency-based model of a specialist/paramedic/general practitioner and nurses at the stage of primary health care. A prognostic analysis of the show that the result will be achieved the optimal availability and quality of primary health care, the coverage of a medical examination of up to 99% of the population, a decrease in total and maternal incidence and mortality.
This paper examines the technical and technological possibility of providing citizens with information about the results of all ongoing quality checks of medical care provided to them, and also makes an attempt to study the subjective attitude of citizens to this kind of information. For this purpose, an analysis of the existing regulatory legal framework (federal laws, by-laws) was carried out, and research was conducted in the form of a survey among 50 respondents. The percentage of Russians with access to state and municipal services (not only in digital form) in the country exceeds 97%, of which more than 76% use electronic services. Among all inspections, the vast majority relate to the compulsory health insurance system, and only 0.2% of the activities are carried out at the request of citizens, with the results of the inspection subsequently provided to them. Modeling, during a social experiment, a situation where a citizen who previously had no complaints about the quality (results) of medical services provided, received control results, shows, first of all, the emergence of aggression and the desire to “punish” a medical organization, rather than resolve the issue of the impact of such a violation on his health, with determination of tactics (if necessary) for continuing treatment.
The article examines the role of ultrasound diagnostics (ultrasound) in emergency medical care, its significant impact on the speed and accuracy of diagnosis in emergency situations. The advantages of ultrasound, such as non-invasiveness, mobility and cost-effectiveness, which make this method indispensable in critical conditions, are emphasized. The evolution of ultrasound technology is described, including the development of portable ultrasound scanners and the introduction of FAST examination protocols that allow doctors to quickly assess the condition of patients and make vital decisions. Attention is also paid to the social and economic aspects of the introduction of ultrasound into medical practice.
The purpose of the study: to perform an analysis compliance as a social characteristic of a patient in the formation of his assessment of the professional qualities of a doctor. Materials and methods. The data for the analysis were obtained by questioning 502 patients of medical organizations in Moscow providing medical care in outpatient settings. The first group (the main one) included patients with a high level of compliance — 197 patients. The second group (control) included patients with a low level of compliance — 131 patients. Taking into account the nonparametric distribution of primary data, a nonparametric analogue of the correlation coefficient, the association coefficient, was used to identify the relationship, and the criterion of the reliability of differences was used to compare groups. Results. Patients who were more committed to treatment (compliant) trusted formal criteria more, such as having a qualification category or an academic degree. Regardless of the degree of compliance when choosing a doctor, patients most appreciate the feedback of patients who have already been treated by this doctor. The second most important was the previous experience of contacting this doctor, and this was of great importance among the patients of the main group. Such patients were more based on their opinion, despite the fact that they might not have had experience of contacting this doctor. They are more likely to listen to the opinions of other doctors, ratings of doctors on the websites of medical organizations and virtual patients (reviews on the Internet), in respect of which the degree of trust is certainly lower. Mass media and advertising have almost no meaning when choosing a doctor for patients. When choosing a medical organization, patients are primarily guided by the presence of competent specialists in the staff of the organization and a good reputation of the medical organization. These signs were more important among patients with a high degree of compliance. For such patients, a clear organization of work was important and they regarded these signs as more important compared to patients with a low degree of compliance. Geographical and temporal accessibility, as well as the cheapness of paid services, were of less importance.
Efficiency underlies application of any method of treatment in clinical practice. However, its wide use is impossible without adequate legal regulation. The existing regulatory legal acts concerning applications of the blood purification methods in practice in the Russian Federation are analysed in article.
Адрес: 105064, г. Москва, ул. Воронцово Поле, д. 12, стр. 1
Email: r.bulletin@yandex.ru
Телефон: +7 (495) 917-90-41 доп. 143
Кузьмина Юлия Александровна
FSSBI «N.A. Semashko National Research Institute of Public Health»
E-mail: